Welcome to Rock Solid, where we fill in the blank. Our goal is to pseudo-scientifically determine the best, the beloved, the most classic album in an artist's catalog.
Here's how it works: I've consulted two main sources. The All Music Guide provides the professional critical point-of-view and Amazon.com offers the fan perspective (because most people who choose to review albums on Amazon are adoring fans of the artist in question). The album with the highest combined rating from both sources is the one I'll consider the best.
An artist's entire body of work is eligible, with one exception: No compilations (i.e. greatest hits). In each case, I'll also share my personal favorite album by the artist in question, as if you care.
* * *
For over 30 years - from 1967 to 2000 - there was a no-brainer answer to which Beatles album was considered the best: Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band. Duh. There was little argument about this; it was the accepted storyline. In fact, many claimed it as not only the best Beatles album, but the best album OF ALL TIME!
So what happened in 2000? Well, Q Magazine released a list of the 100 Greatest British Albums Ever, and of course The Beatles were at the top. But not Sgt. Pepper. Instead its predecessor, Revolver, got the nod. No big deal, a contrarian fluke, right? Well, a year later, VH1 and Virgin both followed in Q's footsteps, naming Revolver the best album of all time. Suddenly what was once a lopsided blowout had become a closely contested game!
Last year Rolling Stone attempted to correct course on the narrative by putting Sgt. Pepper back on top of their 500 Greatest Albums of All Time list, with Revolver at a lowly #3. Then just this past June, Entertainment Weekly fired another shot across the bow, putting Revolver at the head of their 100 Greatest All Time Albums list, AND LEAVING SGT. PEPPER COMPLETELY OFF! (This despite the presence of 3 other Beatles albums on the list).
Has history changed, right before our very eyes? The only real way to find out is our tried and (partially) true Rock Solid method.
First, we look at the All Music Guide. According to them, every official Beatles studio album except 1970's Let It Be is a five star masterpiece. Besides being untrue, it's also unhelpful. We're left to parse what we can from the reviews themselves. Luckily, there are two statements that stand out. In the review of Sgt. Pepper Stephen Thomas Erlewine states (emphasis mine): "It's possible to argue that there are better Beatles albums, yet no album is as historically important as this." And in regards to Revolver: "Even after Sgt. Pepper, Revolver stands as the ultimate modern pop album." After some careful parsing, it sounds to me like All Music is calling it in favor of Revolver.
Thankfully Amazon.com reviewers agree. They bestowed four and a half stars on nearly every Beatles album, but considering the percentage of 5 star reviews, Revolver tops them all with 83%. (By this measure Sgt. Pepper actually came in sixth place overall, behind Rubber Soul, Abbey Road, A Hard Day's Night, and the White Album.) And thus we have consensus. Revolver is the best Beatles album.
Erlewine says Revolver's "daring sonic adventures and consistently stunning songcraft set the standard for what pop/rock could achieve." He also believes that The Beatles' feat of making an album that flows "perfectly" and yet incorporates several musical styles is a "miracle".
Amazon.com reviewers are similarly praiseful:
- Mike London: "Everything that made The Beatles great is here in the right proportions."
- Jack Wolverton: "The album is flawless from every note played to every word sung, it's seemless [sic] and timeless."
- Paperbackwriter: "A mind boggling college of perfect songcraft and sheer sonic joy."
- A Kid's Review: "If you are a (classic) rock fan and do not have this album, HANG YOUR HEAD IN SHAME."
- A Customer: "Of COURSE it's a masterpiece. Just listen to it! Oh, and if a little troll from Norway comes along to tell you differently, kindly lead him back to the gangsta rap section."
- H. Jin: "If you consider that Sgt. Pepper is mainly a consolidation of these experiments rather than an artistic breakthrough in its own right, you could argue that Revolver is The Beatles' best album. Certainly, in terms of a deliberate redefining of the band's sound, ambition and (most importantly) image, it can be regarded as their most significant." (Question: Is image really the most important thing here?)
- Janan Ganesh: "Rubber Soul is entertaining but lacks ambition, Sgt. Pepper is pretentious and unfulfilling, Abbey Road is sporadically brilliant but more often indulgent, and the White Album is just poor. Revolver, however, is a masterpiece." (So, Revolver is ambitious, unpretentious, fulfilling, non-indulgent, and rich, but Janan Ganesh is not really much of a Beatles fan.)
- Dustin D. Boucher (who goes by the nickname "ledzeppelin6785"): "The Beatles' Revolver is without a doubt the best album put out by The Beatles or anybody." (Really, Dustin, even better than Coda?)
- Donaldo: "In the words of both John Lennon & George Martin (this is not verbatim): "We never topped Revolver" ---- ' nuff said." (Donaldo, I'm going to need to see your sources.)
- Randy Scott Bailin: "Who can say what's best? Art is and always will be subjective." (Shush, Randy! You're making too much sense!)
Is it the inevitable contrarian backlash against Sgt. Pepper being considered "the best" for such a very long time? I wouldn't put this past the rock critic majority.
Is it the fact that the (mostly) guitar pop of Revolver seems more modern and relevant than the vaudevillain psychedelic pop of Sgt. Pepper? Maybe, but if that's the case you'd think the White Album would have ascended, since it presages indie rock (Dear Prudence), alt-country (Bungalow Bill), hard rock (Birthday), and heavy metal (Helter Skelter).
Is it the realization that, for all its ambition and audacity, Sgt. Pepper has arguable weak points (Lovely Rita, Within You Without You)? Perhaps Revolver's consistency made it the tortoise to Sgt. Pepper's hare.
Maybe it's a combination of all three. I honestly don't know. I do know that when I reviewed all of The Beatles' albums back in aught eight, I gave perfect scores to four of them: A Hard Day's Night, Revolver, Sgt. Pepper, and Abbey Road. I still feel that way, though depending on which way the wind is blowing, I can be talked into including the White Album, if only for its sheer breadth. But my personal favorite is and likely always will be Abbey Road. It's got the individual songs, the ambition, the emotion, the cover art, and the songwriting balance to be worth returning to over and over.
Who knows, maybe in 2033 it'll will overtake Revolver as the consensus best album of all time.